After three years on the title, 74 issues plus a whole lot of extras Nick Spencer wrapped up his run in “The Amazing Spider-Man” in a mammoth conclusion that plants seeds for future stories and shakes up the status quo while doubling down on the elements that make the superhero so beloved.
Spencer’s final Spider-Man story is devoid of the red herrings, clues and teases that dominated the ‘Kindred’ saga. Spider-Man faced off against the deadliest new foe he’s encountered in a long time, but after barely escaping being beaten to a bloody pulp by the entirety of his Rogue’s Gallery, he’s at a low point.
Luckily, Harry Osborn- or his clone- swoops in to help save the day. He straps on his old Goblin Glider, loads up on the bombs and jumps into the fray alongside Spider-Man in a turn plucked straight out of the climax in ‘Spider-Man 3’.
As in that movie, it end with Harry being killed. RIP Harry. We’ll miss you until your resurrection.
But it turns out the real villain all this time has been none other the devil Mephisto. This is where things get interesting, though it requires a little backstory.
In the story “Civil War”, Peter Parker unmasked his identity to the world to support Iron Man. He’d later come to regret it: Not only did he switch allegiance to Captain America, but Aunt May was fatally injured in a sniper attack that was meant to kill him. Peter made a bargain with the devil to save his aunt’s life and to make the world forget that he was Spider-Man. In the controversial comic “One More Day”, Mephisto extracted a heavy price: He took Peter’s and Mary Jane’s marriage. In one move, over ten years of their relationship were wiped out.
And fans have been pissed since! “One More Day” remains reviled in the Spider-Man saga. It’s hard to read it even today without getting worked up. It would be like if DC Comics erased the Superman-Lois Lane relationship, an integral part of the Boy Scout’s story. But Marvel editor Joe Quesada believed marriage and maturity would turn off fans, so he decreed that Peter return to bachelorhood. Meanwhile, over at DC, Superman and Batman’s stories evolved to their becoming parents and mentoring their children as the next generation of superheroes.
When Spencer took over writing duties in 2018, his first move in Issue #1 itself (as the title got a new volume) was to get Peter and Mary Jane back together. Best decision ever: Even when the story has dragged or gotten frustrating, the relationship has remained a burning pillar of hope. As time progressed, however, there were also hints that Spencer was going to undo the events of ‘One More Day’. Now that he’s arrived at the end: Has he?
Not… quite. But he did undo one of the other controversial elements in Spider-lore: He erased a creepy and controversial relationship between Norman Osborn and Gwen Stacy in which the latter had twins by Osborn called Sarah and Gabriel. Turned out that the whole thing was a scheme concocted ages ago by the real Harry Osborn to torment Peter and Norman. Details details.
However, Spencer did provide an answer as to why Mephisto was so eager to erase Peter’s and MJ’s relationship, and it’s quite tantalising.
Dr Strange and Mephisto battled it out over a game of roulette to see who would win: Spider-Man or Kindred. Yes, the devil was behind Kindred. But why is he so eager to get rid of Spider-Man?
It turns out that Mephisto knows that the world is about to end sometime in the next hundred years. He has foreseen this. A planet consumed in fire, and the devil reigning above on his throne. All the heroes are dead. Except one: Spider-Man. The only one who can stop him.
Only, that’s not the entire truth.
Yes, the world has ended and the heroes are dead… in the future. The only one who can stop him is not Spider-Man, but actually Spider-Man’s daughter, May “Mayday” Parker. Mephisto simply wanted to avert this threat to his glory by making sure Peter and MJ never have a child.
Well, “One More Day” might not have been completely dumped into the forget file. But it does push back against it by ending the comic with Peter and MJ firmly committed to their relationship, their bond stronger than it has ever been.
Let’s just hope future writers don’t ruin a good thing. If it ain’t broke: Leave it.
I’ve been following the Spider-Man comics religiously since 2012. But somehow, I think this is where I might leave off. It’s been a good run, but it’s time to turn my attention to new stories. If you ever happen to stumble across this, Nick Spencer: Thanks for the story, it was a blast.